Not automatically. An older consumer unit or one without RCD protection doesn’t meet the current edition of BS 7671, but the inspector codes it according to actual risk. Missing RCD protection is often coded C3, but can be C2 where it creates real danger, for example sockets likely to be used for equipment outdoors. Damage, overheating or no earthing are far more likely to fail.
Typical coding outcomes
| Finding | Typical code |
|---|---|
| Old but sound consumer unit without RCDs | Often C3, sometimes C2 depending on use |
| Plastic consumer unit in good condition | Usually no code, or C3 |
| Rewireable fuses in good condition | Often C3 |
| Signs of overheating or burning | C2 or C1 |
| Missing covers or blanks, exposing live parts | C1 or C2 |
| No main earthing | C2 or C1 |
Coding depends on the circumstances. Electrical Safety First’s Best Practice Guide 4 is the reference most inspectors use.
When an upgrade makes sense anyway
- You’re adding an EV charger, heat pump or solar and battery system.
- The consumer unit is full, or damaged.
- You want RCD protection on every circuit for safety and peace of mind.
Frequently asked questions
Does a plastic consumer unit fail an EICR?
Not on its own, if it’s in good condition.
Is an RCD required for an EICR to pass?
Not always. Its absence is coded on risk, often C3.
How much is a new consumer unit?
It varies with the number of circuits and any remedial work found. Get a fixed quote.
Related guides
Sources
- Electrical Safety First: Guidance for landlords and homeowners
- IET: Inspection and testing FAQs (Guidance Note 3, Table 3.2)
This guide is general information, not legal advice. Rules differ between England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland.